≡ Menu

Sweets for the Sweet

One of our many projects this summer has been the re-design of Sarah’s Sweet Shoppe.  After watching how it worked as a fudge shop for the last couple of years, we decided it just needed a little TLC to make it a fun place to find your favorite nostalgic candies and sweets.

The Sweet Shoppe is the showcase for our delicious fresh-made fudge.  We have been making our fudge for many years, and continue to carry over a dozen flavors to indulge your sweet tooth.

We wanted to add to our amazing fudge, so we took a poll of our family and friends and came up with a list of their favorite childhood candies.  We are very excited to be carrying a great selection of nostalgic candies. And, just because we thought there was better taffy out there, we did some taste testing and the results are in … we have switched our salt water taffy company to Zeno’s, known as “The Best Taffy in the World!

Also available in the Sweet Shoppe is a selection of packaged Apple Cider Donuts and Caramel Apples, made fresh in our bakery all weekend.  (For a wider selection of baked goods, visit our Bakery Barn!)

Make sure you stop by Sarah’s Sweet Shoppe during your visit to Schuster’s to create some very sweet memories!